D Gukesh, the youngest chess world champion, stirs debate with his Gukesh World Title win. At 18, he claimed the crown in December 2024, defeating Ding Liren in a thrilling 14-game classical match. Yet, critics, including Magnus Carlsen’s former aide Jon Ludvig Hammer, question his ability to dominate. Despite doubts, Gukesh’s record-breaking achievements signal a bright future for chess.
Gukesh World Title Sparks Debate
Gukesh’s meteoric rise captivates chess fans. He earned his Gukesh World Title shot by winning the 2024 FIDE Candidates at 17, a historic feat. His victory over Ding Liren showcased sharp calculation and resilience. However, Hammer, a Norwegian grandmaster, argues Gukesh lacks the dominance of legends like Carlsen or Kasparov. “Challengers and the champion are roughly the same strength,” Hammer told Take Take Take. He believes a true champion must hold the title long-term to cement legitimacy.
Magnus Carlsen, who vacated the title in 2022, also critiqued the classical format after Gukesh’s win. He suggested it may not always crown the best player. Despite this, Gukesh’s classical prowess remains undeniable. His ability to navigate complex positions over long games sets him apart.
Also Read: What Stops Indian Grandmasters from Excelling in Freestyle Chess?
Rising Star or Short-Lived Reign?
Critics point to Gukesh’s recent struggles, like his 11th-place finish at the Freestyle Chess Grand Slam in Paris. Freestyle chess, a variant with randomized starting positions, tests adaptability. Gukesh excels in classical formats, not freestyle, so this result hardly dims his credentials. At 18, he continues to grow. His Chennai roots and rigorous training under coach Vishnu Prasanna fuel his potential.
FIDE data shows Gukesh’s peak rating of 2766, placing him among the world’s elite. He faces stiff competition from players like Fabiano Caruana and Hikaru Nakamura, who may challenge in 2026. Hammer warns that a revolving door of champions could weaken the title’s prestige. Yet, Gukesh’s youth offers time to refine his game. “It would be great if Gukesh keeps his title for a prolonged period,” Hammer added.
Gukesh’s journey inspires young players globally. His Gukesh World Title win proves talent can triumph early. As he prepares to defend his crown, the chess world watches closely. Will he silence doubters or face a new challenger? Only time will tell.
Also Read: How Gukesh Deals with Haters After the World Championship Win
